Judge Issues Ruling on Timothy Busfield’s Release as Melissa Gilbert Reacts

The charges against Busfield relate to allegations of improper conduct with minor cast members while directing episodes of the television drama The Cleaning Lady, filmed in New Mexico. Law enforcement has charged him with two counts of criminal sexual contact of a minor and one count of child abuse. Busfield has denied all allegations and stated that he intends to contest the charges throughout the judicial process.

During the hearing, Judge David Murphy weighed arguments from both the prosecution and defense. Prosecutors urged continued detention, citing the seriousness of the accusations. However, the judge noted that the evidence at this stage was “neutral” and that Busfield had no prior criminal record. He determined that, under specific conditions, Busfield did not pose an undue risk to the community. These conditions include supervision by pretrial services and adherence to court-imposed restrictions.

The hearing was emotionally charged for Busfield’s family. His wife, actress Melissa Gilbert, was visibly emotional in the courtroom, while supporters—including family and colleagues—submitted letters vouching for his character. Gilbert has expressed concern for her husband’s wellbeing and gratitude following the ruling.

Under the terms of his release, Busfield may reside at home under supervision, must avoid unsupervised contact with minors, and comply with all directives from pretrial officers. A preliminary hearing is scheduled to determine if there is sufficient evidence to proceed to trial. No finding of guilt has been made, and Busfield continues to maintain his innocence as the case moves through the judicial process.